2
PERCEPTION DE L'ESPACE 291 lancement ~t distance. Et aussi avec le choc A distance on peut obtenir un effet cauml tr~s marqu6 en aceentuant la hi6rarchie des vitesses. Nos exlxSriences montrent que l'orientation des deux mouvements, de l'agent et du patient, clans la mSme direction ou dans des directions peu diver$cntes est *galement une condition tr~ favorable, mais pas absolument n~:essaire, car en compensant l'absence de cette condition on peut aussi obtenir une impression causale lorsque le mouvement du patient se d6ve- loppe clans une direction diam~tralement oppost.~e A celle du mouvement de l'agent. De cette faqon on a pu produire des effets paradoxaux de lancement invers6 /~ distance; tandis qut: d'autres situations, au lieu d'etre v~cues comme formes de lancement, r~alisent sur le plan ph~nom6nal des im- pressions d'attraction active. On a obtenu aussi ce meme ph6nom~ne d'attraction dans des situations qui ne sont pas assimilables au lancement mais semblent pr~cnter une affinit6 avee l'effet entrainement. Du point de rue th6orique ces ph~nom~nes semblent rentrer, sans effort, dans 1¢cadre du sch6ma interpr~tatif du Pr. Michotte, fond6 sur l'aml~ liation du mouvement. A STUDY OF STABILITY OF DISCRIMINATION IN A VISUAL MATCHING TEST BY FORREST L. DLMMICK (U.S. Naval Medical Research laboratory, New London, Conn. ) Since color matching is based upon discrimination of differences, the scatter ofa succes~fion of repeated matches will reflect the normal distribution of discrimination judgments. To evaluate this relationship, each one of a group of six subjects repeated a test of 40 matches ten times. The matching colors consisted of ten saturation steps in each one of the principal hues, red, yellow, green, and blue. Differences between adjacent steps in the series were of a size that precluded correct matching of all 40 samples by any subject except in very rare cases. It was found that (a) the group was relatively homogeneous with mean scores rangi,lg from 61-70, (b) th~ standard deviations were small, ranging from 4- 4 to 4- 8, (c) the data i~Micated that more precise measures may

A study of stability of discrimination in a visual matching test

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • PERCEPTION DE L'ESPACE 291

    lancement ~t distance. Et aussi avec le choc A distance on peut obtenir un effet cauml tr~s marqu6 en aceentuant la hi6rarchie des vitesses.

    Nos exlxSriences montrent que l'orientation des deux mouvements, de l'agent et du patient, clans la mSme direction ou dans des directions peu diver$cntes est *galement une condition t r~ favorable, mais pas absolument n~:essaire, car en compensant l'absence de cette condition on peut aussi obtenir une impression causale lorsque le mouvement du patient se d6ve- loppe clans une direction diam~tralement oppost.~e A celle du mouvement de l'agent.

    De cette faqon on a pu produire des effets paradoxaux de lancement invers6 /~ distance; tandis qut: d'autres situations, au lieu d'etre v~cues comme formes de lancement, r~alisent sur le plan ph~nom6nal des im- pressions d'attraction active. On a obtenu aussi ce meme ph6nom~ne d'attraction dans des situations qui ne sont pas assimilables au lancement mais semblent pr~cnter une affinit6 avee l'effet entrainement.

    Du point de rue th6orique ces ph~nom~nes semblent rentrer, sans effort, dans 1 cadre du sch6ma interpr~tatif du Pr. Michotte, fond6 sur l'aml~ liation du mouvement.

    A STUDY OF STABILITY OF DISCRIMINATION IN A VISUAL

    MATCHING TEST

    BY

    FORREST L. DLMMICK

    (U.S. Naval Medical Research laboratory, New London, Conn. )

    Since color matching is based upon discrimination of differences, the scatter ofa succes~fion of repeated matches will reflect the normal distribution of discrimination judgments. To evaluate this relationship, each one of a group of six subjects repeated a test of 40 matches ten times. The matching colors consisted of ten saturation steps in each one of the principal hues, red, yellow, green, and blue. Differences between adjacent steps in the series were of a size that precluded correct matching of all 40 samples by any subject except in very rare cases.

    It was found that (a) the group was relatively homogeneous with mean scores rangi,lg from 61-70, (b) th~ standard deviations were small, ranging from 4- 4 to 4- 8, (c) the data i~Micated that more precise measures may

  • 292 ~u~ 10

    be obtained by several successive tests of any given subject, and (d) the judL, ments were normally distributed.

    The distributions of errors for each of the four hues were essentially the same. The standard deviation of each distribution was computed. T!~ese were arbitrary units differing in the case of each hue. The standard deviations of the red and the yellow hues were compared with the just- noticeable-differences of saturation for comparable colors from a previous study. It is interesting that these two just-noticeable-differences had almost identical ratios to the standard deviations of the present analysis.

    Observation of techniques used in matching and reports from subjects indicated that a "match" was never a simple and direct judgment of equality. It was instead an inference from, or an evaluation of, a number of discrimina- tions or judgments of difference. For most observers, the possibilities of match were quickly reduced to two or three chips that were not readily discriminated as different. The final choice tended to reflect the humor of times each pair of chips was discriminated. Single matches, obviously, were not fixed. This accounts for the greater stability of scores with repeated testing.

    SOME CONTRIBIY(IONS TO THE STUDY OF COMPLEX

    PERCEPTIONS

    BY

    ENZO SPM.TRO

    ( Universint Cattolica. Milano)

    Perceptive structures are often influenced by non-perceptive structures. However the researches about the subjective males of evaluation seem to find that these non-perceptive structures can be employed for a "measure- ment" of the perceptive structures.

    Otherwise the uncertain income is very important in the forming of perceptive structures: this uncertain income is the "aspettativa" that a perceptive event may happen; the researches about the subjective probability seem to have proved all 'this.

    In this research the aether has been searching a rational point of view in the study of the problem of the importance that some evaluative structures have in the forming of a "complex perception".

    That, which was studied, of a linear mathematical function is the founda-